Skid Steer vs Track Loader: Which Rental Is Better in Mud & Snow?

Skid Steer vs Compact Track Loader: Better for Mud, Snow & Soft Ground?

If you’ve ever tried to move material during a Maine spring thaw, you already know the problem: the job looks simple until the ground turns into pudding. One minute you’re grading a pad or hauling gravel, the next minute you’re spinning tires, cutting ruts, and wondering how “one quick project” became an all-day recovery mission.


That’s why so many people get stuck on the same question:

Should I rent a skid steer (wheels) or a compact track loader (tracks)?



They both load. They both lift. They both run a huge range of attachments. But when you’re working in mud season, snow and slush, or soft lawns, they feel like completely different machines.


In Maine (and across NH/MA), ground conditions change fast. Spring mud, soft lawns, and winter slush can turn the wrong loader into ruts, downtime, or a stuck machine.



Here’s the straight answer:

Skid Steer vs Track Loader: Which Rental is better for mud & snow

Skid Steer (wheels):


Best on firm ground, pavement, and hard-packed gravel

Compact Track Loader (tracks / CTL):


Best on mud, snow, and soft ground

Easy Rent All carries both — including wheeled options like the CASE SV280 and tracked options like the CASE TR310, Kubota SVL65-2, and Kubota SVL75-3 — plus mini track loaders for tight access like the Vermeer S725TX and Barreto 825TKL

SKID STEER VS TRACK LOADER QUICK PICK GUIDE

Go with tracks (CTL) if the ground is:


  • Uneven or slippery where traction matters


  • Mud / saturated soil / spring thaw


  • Soft lawn / sand / loam


  • Snow / slush

Go with wheels if you’re mostly on:


  • Dry, stable sites where you’re loading, moving, and cycling fast


  • Concrete / pavement


  • Hard-packed gravel



LET'S BREAK IT DOWN BY JOB SITE

Mud & soft ground: tracks usually win


Mud season is where CTLs earn their keep. Tracks spread weight out and keep you moving with less spin and fewer ruts.


If your site is soft or saturated, start here:


When wheels can still work:
If you’re on a solid base (packed gravel) and the job is mostly loading/truck work, a wheeled skid steer like the CASE SV280 is a cost-effective choice.


Pro Tip: If you wouldn’t drive a pickup across it without leaving marks, rent tracks.

Snow & slush: traction and control matter


In winter conditions, tracked loaders typically give you more consistent traction and stability on uneven ground.


Good options to start with:


Tight winter work (walkways, gates, backyards):


Soft lawns: “don’t wreck the yard”


If you’re working on turf, tracks are usually the safer call — especially mini tracks for residential access.


Start with:


Pro tip: Don’t pivot hard in place. Make wider turns to reduce scuffing.

Hard surfaces: wheels can be the better tool


Working on pavement, concrete, or firm gravel? A wheeled skid steer is efficient and quick for loading cycles and material handling.


Start with:

Bottom line: which one should you rent?

Mud / snow / soft ground:

choose track skid steer rental

arrow

Firm ground/lots of loading cycles:

choose wheel skid steer rental

arrow

Start here:

CASE SV280

Tight access / backyard work:

choose a mini track skid steer

arrow

Rent near me: FAQ

  • Do you deliver equipment rentals near me?

    Yes—delivery is available, including service into NH and MA. Use delivery to save time and avoid trailer logistics.

  • Can I rent a mini track loader near me for backyard access?

    Yes—mini track loaders are ideal for tight access and residential jobs (gates, tight yards, close quarters).

  • Do I need a trailer to rent a skid steer or track loader?

    If you’re picking up, you’ll need appropriate towing capacity and secure transport. If you’d rather skip that, choose delivery.

  • How much does it cost to rent a skid steer or track loader near me?

    Pricing depends on the machine size, rental duration, and delivery distance. The fastest way to get accurate numbers is to request a quote for your dates and location.

    Get A Quote

  • Can I get a same-day equipment rental near me?

    Availability changes daily. Call or request a quote early—especially during spring mud season and after storms—so we can reserve the right machine.

    Call To Reserve
A man is mowing a lawn next to a truck that says your lawn service

How to Start a Thriving Landscaping Business with Easy Rent All

By Emmanuel Boucher • February 28, 2025
This is a subtitle for your new post
the sun is shining through the branches of a tree over a lake .

Spring Preparation with Easy Rent All

February 8, 2024
In this detailed guide, we'll thoroughly explore how you can effectively prepare for the spring season with the diverse range of product rentals offered by Easy Rent All.
two tall buildings are against a blue sky with clouds .

Why Renting Equipment is a Profitable Business Strategy: Insights from Easy Rent All

September 8, 2023
At Easy Rent All, we've seen firsthand how choosing to rent rather than purchase equipment outright can be a profitable business strategy. Here's why.
a car is parked in front of a house with the sun shining through the windows

Home Improvement Made Easier

September 1, 2023
Home improvement projects can be exciting but also a little daunting. From landscaping to renovations, these tasks often require specialized tools and equipment. Fortunately, Easy Rent All has got you covered. With an extensive range of rental equipment, you can tackle any home improvement project with ease. Let's explore some of the improvements you can make using equipment from Easy Rent All.
a large empty room with a marble floor and walls .

Epoxy vs Paint - An Easy & Comprehensive Guide

September 1, 2023
When it comes to improving the look and durability of your floors, two popular options are epoxy and paint. Both have their advantages and offer unique benefits. But how do you decide which one is right for your specific needs? This blog post will explore the differences between epoxy and paint, their pros and cons, and how Easy Rent All can help you with your flooring project.
there is a tree in the middle of a field with trees in the background .

Season Changes - How To Get Prepared for Fall & Winter

August 31, 2023
As the vibrant colors of fall start to appear and temperatures begin to drop, it's time to start thinking about your fall and winter preparation. Whether you're a homeowner, business owner, or a professional contractor, having the right equipment on hand can make a significant difference in your ability to tackle these seasonal tasks efficiently. That's where Easy Rent All comes in. With a variety of high-quality, reliable equipment available for rent, we can help you get ready for the colder months ahead. Here's a handy guide to help you prepare for fall and winter using our rental services
a large house with a lush green lawn in front of it .

10 Landscaping Project Ideas Utilizing Equipment Rentals from Easy Rent All

July 21, 2023
Landscaping is more than just mowing the lawn or planting flowers; it's about creating a space that enhances your property and brings you joy every time you step outside. However, many people are deterred by the potential cost of buying heavy equipment for their landscaping projects. That's where Easy Rent All comes in. With their diverse range of rental equipment, you can take on any landscaping project with ease.
a group of aerial lifts are parked next to each other in a parking lot .

Scissor Lift vs Boom Lift: Which One is Right for Your Project?

July 21, 2023
When it comes to completing projects that require working at heights, choosing the right equipment is crucial. Scissor lifts and boom lifts are two popular options, each with their own unique features and capabilities. But which one is right for your specific project? In this guide, we'll delve into the key differences between scissor lifts and boom lifts, helping you make an informed decision.
a bulldozer is driving through a dirt field next to a dump truck .

Maine Excavator Rentals: Discover How Easy Rent All Can Help You Get the Job Done Right

July 20, 2023
Renting an excavator from Easy Rent All offers several advantages over purchasing one outright. Firstly, it eliminates the need for a large upfront investment, which can be a significant barrier for many individuals and businesses. Renting also allows you to access a wide range of excavators tailored to different project requirements, without the burden of ownership and maintenance costs.
a large room filled with lots of tools and equipment for rent by Easy Rent All.

From DIY to Professional: Why Easy Rent All Equipment Rentals is Your Go-To

July 14, 2023
Whether you're a DIY enthusiast or a professional contractor, Easy Rent All is the best choice for all your equipment rental needs. With an extensive inventory of the latest tools and equipment, competitive pricing, and exceptional customer service and support, Easy Rent All has become the trusted choice for contractors and DIYers alike. So why struggle with outdated equipment or pay for expensive gear you only need for a short period of time? Turn to Easy Rent All and experience the convenience and affordability of renting top-quality equipment for your next project.